TAXTEMBER: How Direct Indexing Can Help Reduce Taxes

TAXTEMBER: How Direct Indexing Can Help Reduce Taxes

September 30, 2026

For many investors, an S&P 500 fund is the foundation of their investment portfolio. Low-cost ETFs such as the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO) provide broad exposure to 500 of the largest U.S. companies and offer a simple, efficient way to participate in the stock market.

However, for investors with taxable investment accounts, there may be an opportunity to achieve similar market exposure while potentially improving after-tax results through a strategy known as direct indexing.

Direct indexing has become increasingly popular in recent years, thanks in part to advances in technology and the elimination of trading commissions. While the goal is still to track the performance of the S&P 500, direct indexing creates opportunities to capture tax benefits that are difficult to achieve with a traditional index fund or ETF.

What Is Direct Indexing?

Traditional index investing involves purchasing a single ETF or mutual fund that owns all 500 companies in the S&P 500.

Direct indexing takes a different approach. Instead of owning one fund, investors own the underlying securities, or a representative sample of them, directly like buying the stocks from A(pple) to Z(ebra Technologies). In simple terms, you own the individual building blocks of the index rather than the package itself.  The objective remains the same: closely track the performance of the S&P 500 while creating opportunities to generate tax savings along the way.

When individual holdings decline in value, they can potentially be sold to realize a tax loss while maintaining similar market exposure through replacement investments. This can create additional value for investors by helping reduce future tax liabilities.

Understanding Tax-Loss Harvesting

Tax-loss harvesting involves selling investments that have declined in value to generate losses that can offset capital gains elsewhere in a portfolio.

For example, if an investor realizes a $10,000 gain from one investment and also realizes a $10,000 loss from another investment, the loss may offset the gain, potentially eliminating the associated capital gains tax.  Any unused losses may be carried forward into future years and can also offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income annually.

One important consideration is the IRS wash sale rule. When a security is sold for a loss, the investor generally cannot repurchase that same security within 30 days. Instead, a similar investment is often purchased to maintain market exposure. Think of it as selling Coca Cola and temporarily replacing it with another Pepsi while waiting for the wash-sale period to pass.

Why 2025 Was a Great Example

The market environment in 2025 provided a real-world example of why direct indexing can be valuable.  The first quarter brought increased volatility as investors reacted to economic uncertainty and tariff announcements. Many individual stocks and sectors experienced meaningful declines during the market selloff.

For investors holding a traditional S&P 500 ETF, those declines were largely temporary. The losses appeared on account statements for a brief period and then disappeared as the market recovered.  For direct indexing investors, however, those temporary declines represented an opportunity.

Individual stocks or sectors that had declined could be sold to realize tax losses and replaced with similar investments. As the market rebounded throughout the remainder of the year and ultimately finished with strong double-digit gains, investors remained invested while retaining the value of the harvested tax losses.

In other words, they participated in the market recovery while building a reserve of tax losses that may help offset future gains.

Two Approaches to Direct Indexing

While the concept is straightforward, there are two primary ways to implement a direct indexing strategy.

Approach #1: Individual Stock Direct Indexing

The method most investors hear about involves purchasing a large collection of individual stocks designed to closely track the S&P 500.  Depending on the strategy, portfolios may own anywhere from 100 to 300 individual stocks.  The primary advantage is flexibility. With hundreds of positions, there are often numerous opportunities to harvest losses because individual stocks rarely move in lockstep.

However, the approach can come with challenges:

  • Large numbers of trades
  • More complicated portfolio management
  • Lengthy year-end tax reporting
  • Benefits that may diminish over time as gains accumulate
  • Hundreds of individual positions to monitor

For some investors, the added complexity may outweigh the incremental benefits.

Approach #2: The OFS Sector 500 Strategy

At Oldfather Financial Services, we have developed a simpler approach through our OFS Sector 500 Strategy.

Instead of purchasing hundreds of individual stocks, the strategy uses sector ETFs to replicate the exposure of the S&P 500. The portfolio owns investments representing each major sector of the economy, providing broad diversification while still creating opportunities for tax-loss harvesting.

The strategy utilizes the eleven sectors that make up the S&P 500 and may employ ETFs from multiple providers, including Vanguard, State Street, and iShares. Using different ETF families can create opportunities for tax-loss harvesting while remaining mindful of wash-sale rules.

Compared to traditional stock-based direct indexing, the OFS Sector 500 Strategy offers several potential advantages:

  • Simpler implementation
  • Fewer trades
  • Easier portfolio management
  • More streamlined tax reporting
  • Ongoing opportunities for tax-loss harvesting through sector-level changes

In short, the strategy seeks to provide many of the tax-management benefits associated with direct indexing without requiring investors to own and track hundreds of individual stocks.

Is Direct Indexing Right for You?

Direct indexing tends to be most beneficial for investors who:

  • Have sizable taxable investment accounts
  • Are in higher tax brackets
  • Regularly realize capital gains
  • Continue adding money to their investment accounts over time

While direct indexing is not appropriate for every investor, it can be an effective way to potentially improve after-tax outcomes without significantly changing an investor's overall market exposure.

Final Thoughts

Most investors focus on investment returns. While returns matter, what ultimately impacts financial goals is how much of those returns investors get to keep after taxes.  Direct indexing offers a way to maintain exposure to the S&P 500 while creating opportunities for meaningful tax savings along the way.  The lessons of 2025 remind us that market volatility is not always a bad thing. While temporary declines can be uncomfortable, they may also create opportunities. For direct indexing investors, those market pullbacks can potentially become a valuable source of future tax savings.

Taxtember Takeaway

It's not just what your portfolio earns that matters. It's what you get to keep after taxes.

Direct indexing may involve additional trading, costs, and complexity compared to investing in index funds. There can be no guarantee that tax-loss harvesting will produce a tax benefit, or that any harvested losses will be available to offset gains in future periods. Tax benefits, if any, will depend on an investor's individual circumstances, tax status, and applicable tax laws.

Direct indexing and tax-loss harvesting do not guarantee a profit or ensure that investment objectives will be achieved. The implementation of tax-loss harvesting transactions may result in portfolio performance that differs from the performance of the target index and may cause investors to forgo future appreciation in securities sold. Market conditions, trading costs, account size, realized gains, holding periods, tax rates, and other factors may affect the effectiveness of the strategy.

OFS does not provide legal or tax advice. Investors should consult their tax advisor regarding the tax consequences of any investment strategy. Past performance is not indicative of future results.